Jhelum Enterprises LLC won two judgments totaling $54,863.89 against Oceanside Automotive Service and Towing LLC. In 2011, a Palm Beach County court found that Oceanside’s sole officer, Norman Desmarais, fraudulently transferred the company’s assets to himself and a new business to avoid paying the judgment, and held him personally liable for the full amount.
In 2018, Desmarais took out a HECM line of credit and refinanced it in 2022, leaving roughly $62,000 available by January 2024.
According to the decision, the creditor sought to garnish the funds, arguing that prior draws had been used for personal expenses rather than home repairs.
The court rejected that argument, ruling that just because a homeowner has access to funds through a HECM doesn’t mean those funds can be garnished until the homeowner actually requests a draw.
“The undistributed funds are accessible only when requested by the homeowner,” the court wrote.
Florida’s constitution broadly shields homestead property from forced sale or creditor claims, with limited exceptions. The court said that protection extends to undisbursed reverse mortgage funds because they are not yet in the borrower’s possession and may never be accessed.
But the ruling draws a distinction once funds are withdrawn. The court upheld a separate order requiring Desmarais to turn over $250 held in a bank account, finding those funds had lost homestead protection after being disbursed.
The opinion also noted that outcomes could differ in cases involving reverse mortgages that provide automatic monthly payments. In these scenarios, payments already owed to the borrower may be subject to garnishment.
“In conclusion, the trial court properly found the undistributed funds in the reverse mortgage line of credit were protected by Florida’s constitutional homestead exemption,” the decision read.
The ruling marks a question of first impression in Florida, offering new legal clarity on how reverse mortgage credit lines are treated in creditor disputes. The decision noted that it is “not final until disposition of timely-filed motion for rehearing.”
