Prices for new homes have been stagnant for years. That leaves room for potential homebuyers if they’re on the hunt for good incentives.
The latest Realtor.com® quarterly construction insights report shows that prices on new homes are holding steady, but builders are having to get creative to attract buyers, relying on rate buydowns and other incentives as the 30-year fixed mortgage rate stays above 7%.
The median listing price for new builds hit $451,071 in the third quarter. It’s been right around that number since late 2023. Builders are starting fewer homes in the inflation-plagued economy.
Increased labor and material costs and decreased buyer demand led to the completion rate of new single-family homes falling 11.0% year over year in September.
Meanwhile, existing-home prices came in 1.5% below 2025 levels, landing at $402,883. New homes have to compete with existing homes for buyers, and the rise in existing-home sales shows that some cost-conscious buyers who might have built new are choosing existing, instead. Existing-home sales just hit a 16-year low.
“Builders were quicker to adjust to the realities of muted buyer demand in this high-rate environment, while existing-home sellers had pricing expectations based on the market from 2021 and 2022 that were slower to dissolve,” Realtor.com senior economist Joel Berner writes in the report. “The overall price softness we’ve seen through 2026 is driven primarily by the existing-home segment.”
That’s led to more builders and sellers tempering their expectations. Resellers cut prices on 21.6% of homes this quarter. Builders are doing the same for 20.9% of their stock.
“The growing incidence of price reductions for new and existing homes is an indication of softness in the housing market in general and gives reason to expect that the diminished pace of inventory growth will continue,” writes Berner.
Builders lean on incentives
Homebuilders this year are reporting that the difficult housing market is eating into margins. Some have retooled to the higher end of the market, which is less affected by affordability concerns. Others have dangled more incentives to bring buyers calling.
That’s led to some oddities, and it means the market for new homes is, in a lot of ways, buyer-friendly.
For instance, existing homes are more expensive than new ones based on the price per square foot: $218 for new homes, $219 for existing ones. That’s because, while there’s a $50,000 gap between the median new-home price and the median existing-home price, new homes are bigger: a median of 2,056 square feet compared to 1,790 square feet. So, adjusting for size, this price gap disappears.
Also, new builds are concentrated in the South, where land is cheaper. Existing-home sales in the much more expensive Northeast, meanwhile, drives up the data. So, nationally, the median sales price for new homes was $400,400 while for existing homes it was $417,500.
For builders, reduced rates are the most common type of buyer incentive, helping homebuyers cut down on the total cost of ownership. This quarter, the average starting mortgage rate for new-home buyers was 5.01%. For existing-home buyers, it was 6.15%.
“In today’s environment of higher-for-longer mortgage rates, this is an enticing marketing strategy. Builders often have strong relationships with mortgage lenders to whom they send lots of their buyers, and in exchange for this volume of loan origination, the lenders can offer below-market rates.”
But the savings aren’t always permanent. But even with temporary benefits, like the popular 3/2/1 step-down, buyers still see a big benefit in cost savings.
Price growth expected to remain soft
With inflation high and mortgage rates elevated, what’s going to break the cycle?
The housing market over the next year will remain challenged, Goldman Sachs said in its latest forecast. It predicts home prices will keep growing at an “anemic” 1% in 2027.
“In 2027, we expect the headwind from affordability to increasingly dominate, weighing further on activity,” economists Ronnie Walker and David Mericle wrote. “The combination of mortgage borrowers refinancing at low rates en masse in 2020 and 2021 and the high current level of mortgage rates has created a significant financial cost to moving.”
If mortgage rates do start to come down next year, that could bring buyers off the sidelines and cause housing activity to pick up. Goldman projected that could be the case in late 2027.
Some areas are more immune. Maor Greenberg, co-founder and CEO of structural engineer Spacial, says builders feel squeezed by rate hikes, as carrying costs go up on houses that are already under construction. Then, the buyer deals with a higher mortgage rate. The higher end of the market and booming areas like the tech-awash San Francisco Bay Area are rare exceptions.
“Even in a soft market, there’s a point where starting to build a house makes more sense than waiting for more favorable conditions, because you’re paying money to hold on to land,” Greenberg says. “That moves the problem down to selling: To do that, builders offer incentives and cut prices. Margins get tighter, but you’re not losing as much money.”
Ryan Serhant, speaking exclusively to Realtor.com, recently offered his own advice on the market: Don’t wait for lower rates.
While it might seem like the housing market will stay frozen forever, there are some cities where buyers can get a good deal. And a whole lot of other people are thinking the same thing.
“Everyone wants low rates, they never want what comes with it,” he said. “You know what’ll happen if rates come down? There will be no houses for sale.”
Get real estate news in your inbox